Understanding
Iran: Everything you need to know from Persia to the Islamic Republic, from
Cyrus to Ahmadinehad by William R. Polk examines Iran’s ancient and modern
history. Polk analyzes how Iran’s ancient history has helped shape the nations
culture and ideals. Different factors such as geography, ethnicity, language,
and religion are explained, as is the rise and fall of four Iranian
empires. Where the book really excels is
talking about the events in the twentieth century. Polk actually visited Iran
and spent time there in the 1950’s and 60’s. His experiences there, combined
with his extensive knowledge on Iranian history led him to have a deeper understanding
of the Iranian mentality. Polk feels that American policy makers simply don’t have
a full grasp on Iran and Iranians and that is why so many policies fall short. Polk
believes that if they had a better understanding of Iran, the Iranian regimes
behavior would be less confusing and unpredictable to the American policy
makers. Polk uses history to explain why Iran reacts the way it does to U.S.
policy as an alternative to the mathematical approach policy makers use which
disregard the emotions, perceptions, and fears that help form their reactions to American policies.
Overall Polk’s approach to Iranian foreign policy is very interesting and his
analytical approach to Iran’s history can help one understand how and why things
in Iran have become the way they are.
I'm actually in agreement with what Polk has to say here. It's easy to criticize something on the outside looking in, but when it comes to countries and geopolitics it becomes trickier (as well as costly) due to cultures sometimes not transcending. Great review.
ReplyDelete